|
I listened on CD, Frank himself read the book, it would not have been the same by any other person. The idea of his students writing excuse notes from Adam to God, or Eve to God got their creative juices going.
I had the CD playing in my house while cleaning, in my car while commuting, it was fascinating. I hated doing the sentence thing, I would have understood better with his PEN idea.
It also allowed them to hear other points of view on different topics. It goes quickly.
I was so touched by this one. I often wonder if he was too hard on himself.
Just read the book.
For example, a math teacher is supposed to make sure his students learn math and become proficient at it. To some degree, they did this by 1)caring about the students and 2) convincing them the learning would pay off in some important ways. So I think that McCourt's spat with the school officials was important. However the draw of these movies was that these teachers were able to take bored,angry, underachieving students and convince them of the value of learning.
Good book. My best teachers were ones who showed they cared about me but also knew how to teach. In that sense, I think we was successful to some extent and I do applaud him for caring enough to expose his life deeply to his students. I suppose there are a number of definitions or opinions of what constitutes an exceptional or effective teacher. Some would ask simply: "Did I learn what I was supposed to learn in this class." If so, they would give the teacher a high grade. Holland's Opus (music), Stand and Deliver (math), and Dead Poet's Society (literature). To Sir, With Love, Lean on Me, and Conroy's The Water is Wide may be a little more similar to McCourt's story in that the students learned some "non-intellectual" lessons about life as shared by the teacher directly or indirectly.
It takes both, and I believe McCourt tried to do both. Being a teacher myself, and having enjoyed McCourt's first book, I decided to pick up Teacher Man. This is what happened in some "classroom" movies such as Mr. He saw a glimmer of potential that some of his life experiences could somehow help, enlighten, or motivate the students in this crazy business of life, and he fought the establishment to some degree to make teaching about the real stuff, the hard stuff of life.
Frank McCort's books are well-written and an insight into his life. His Teacher Man resonates with me, an English teacher in an inter-city school.
And so will everyone else. Read this book. The dismal movie version did not motivate me either--and I dismissed McCourt. Have you even wondered what your English teacher was really thinking about his students and his hapless job. McCourt did both, eventually. The book reads swiftly. However upon his recent(2009) demise, I happened upon a television tribute to him including his being interviewed about "Teacher Man". I did not regret it.
Imagine teaching nearly everyday for 30 years and only at the end finding the motivation to finally write something yourself after having talked about writing (and reading) forever. I imagine any teacher, English major, writer or Irishperson will love it. I tried to read Frank McCourt's Angela's Ashes some years ago, and could not slog my way through to the end. He read a passage from the book and I was compelled to give him another try. Those that can do and those that cannot teach.
i haven't finished the book yet, i can't put it down. i love it. he was a great author.
|